Government Technology

Eco-Friendly Lighting May Improve Traffic Circle Safety

November 30, 2012 By

Drivers who feel antsy about navigating through traffic circles — also known as roundabouts — may breathe a little easier when approaching them in the future.

Researchers at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute (RPI) in Troy, N.Y., have developed a new roadway illumination concept that uses low-level lighting with super-reflective markers and roadside vegetation to more clearly identify directional paths and pedestrian crosswalks in and around traffic circles.

Called ecoluminance, the idea was demonstrated twice at a roundabout in Bethlehem, N.Y. According to findings from RPI’s Lighting Research Center (LRC), the results were promising: Roadway edges and pedestrians were more visible than under conventional overhead lighting, and vehicles approaching the roundabout did so with similar or slightly lower speeds.

Led by LRC Director Mark Rea and John Bullough, a senior research scientist with the center, the first test consisted of a single night in 2011, where only one portion of the roundabout was modified, along with some pedestrian and landscape lighting. The second demonstration happened this past June over a period of several days, where the entirety of the ecoluminance concept was evaluated at the traffic circle.

The project was sponsored jointly by the New York State Energy Research and Development Authority and the New York State Department of Transportation (NYSDOT).

Bullough said traffic circles are seen as useful as they tend to reduce delays normally seen at intersections and can reduce the severity of crashes. He explained that you typically don’t see collisions at 90-degree angles at roundabouts because vehicles are usually going in the same direction.

But while traffic circles may be a safety benefit, Bullough said an emerging practice of putting up many high-powered, 250-400 watt streetlights around the area can be a budgetary challenge for the government entity responsible for the maintenance of and power for the lights.

Ecoluminance addressed that issue by using light-emitting diode (LED) lighting on poles that were typically 15 feet high around sidewalks and the roadway — significantly lower to the ground than many conventional streetlights. LED lights also consume less energy.

“Rather than lighting from higher distances and using high levels of light as a blanket on everything, we thought about what people need to see,” Bullough said. “It’s really the contrast that people need to see that may be more important, rather than the absolute light level.”

In addition, the area inside the roundabout was peppered with inkberry shrubs and bushes that have natural reflective properties. The vegetation is “semi-evergreen,” and while it sprouts new leaves each year, the leaves on the plants stay green before they are pushed out by new growth.

Bullough explained that since the roundabout in Bethlehem was about 100 feet in diameter, they used a handful of lights to enhance the reflective power of the inkberry shrubs and existing trees to make the area more visible.

Each of the landscape light fixtures produces just eight or nine watts, a significant reduction to the higher-intensity streetlights that would normally be present around a traffic circle.

Golf ball-sized glass retro-reflective markers were also set up around the curb perimeter of the roundabout to clearly delineate the path of traffic to oncoming vehicles. Retro-reflective surfaces bounce a significant portion of the light directly back at the source, whereas a simple reflective item such as aluminum foil reflects light to a variety of angles with only a small portion going back to the source.

Bullough added that had the demonstration been a permanent installation, those markers would be embedded around the roundabout island.

“What that does is shine the light that comes from approaching vehicles’ headlights back toward the driver, so they basically see this dotted line outline of a circle,” Bullough said. “That really helps make it much more visible.”

As for the future of ecoluminance, don’t expect the concept to become a spin-off business venture from the LRC. Bullough explained it’s now up to the NYSDOT or other transportation agencies to use the findings where they deem it appropriate.

“Depending on the location, [ecoluminance] is almost like an a la carte menu,” he said. “They could use components of the concept to reinforce what they’re doing, and it might allow them to reduce the number of streetlights in some locations or remove overhead street lighting entirely.”

Photo: A roundabout in Bethlehem, N.Y. lit up using the Ecoluminance concept. Courtesy of the Lighting Research Center at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute.

| More


Please Do Your Homework Brian    |    Commented December 3, 2012

If you had, you'd know that a traffic circle and a roundabout are VERY different traffic control devices (at least in the US, which I think is where this article referring to). As different structures, they're names should not be used interchangeably . I almost have to wonder if Mr. Bullough made the mistake in paragraph six, or if the articles author misstated his quote. Wikipedia provides a relatively accurate portrayal of the differences...worth noting is the description in the History section. As usual though, I'm left unimpressed by the level of journalism at an eRepublic website.

Fred Davis    |    Commented December 4, 2012

The comment about traffic circles and roundabouts being very different things is interesting. First, I grew up in Massachusetts, and we used (locally) the two terms interchangeably. Now living quite a distance from there, I have one roundabout in our current area, and see everyone uses the terms interchangeably as well. So the use of them was well understood by me. In addition, I for one would never trust wikipedia anyway. Any good researcher knows to avoid it.

bent expectations    |    Commented December 13, 2012

As rotaries and traffic circles have been built and share similarities with roundabouts (namely they are round and traffic uses them to navigate intersections of some sort) doesn't make them one and the same. While for the typical citizen misuse of the terms has little meaning, however, for someone writing a story on a relatively narrow subject(s) (roundabout and lighting) I expect a modicum of research. As to the validity of Wiki in general, yes there can be some dubious information, however, with respect to this topic, as a transportation professional, they were on the mark. If there was a question in the writers mind, he could have asked for an interview with or comment from someone at NYSDOT. But he didn't, nor did he identify the need for this article, apparently taking whatever RPI said at face value. Is approaching roundabouts at night really an issue that makes a large number of people "feel antsy about navigating through them?" I don't know myself, but if I were writing an article about it, I would for darn sure investigate it a little to find out.

Add Your Comment

You are solely responsible for the content of your comments. We reserve the right to remove comments that are considered profane, vulgar, obscene, factually inaccurate, off-topic, or considered a personal attack.

In Our Library

White Papers | Exclusives Reports | Webinar Archives | Best Practices and Case Studies
McAfee Enterprise Security Manager and Threat Intelligence Exchange
As a part of the Intel® Security product offering, McAfee® Enterprise Security Manager and McAfee Threat Intelligence Exchange work together to provide organizations with exactly what they need to fight advanced threats. You get the situational awareness, actionable intelligence, and instantaneous speed to immediately identify, respond to, and proactively neutralize threats in just milliseconds.
Better security. Better government.
Powering security at all levels of government with simpler, more connected IT.
Cybersecurity in an "All-IP World" Are You Prepared?
In a recent survey conducted by Public CIO, over 125 respondents shared how they protect their environments from cyber threats and the challenges they see in an all-IP world. Read how your cybersecurity strategies and attitudes compare with your peers.
View All

Featured Papers