Government Technology

Long-Range Transportation Planning Doomed to Failure, Says Study



May 28, 2008 By

Federal law requires metropolitan planning organizations to produce long-range transportation plans. According to a new study by the Cato Institute, these plans are not cost-effective, attempt to control residents' behavior through land-use regulation and other means, and use unquantifiable measures to justify extravagant projects.

In "Roadmap to Gridlock: The Failure of Long-Range Metropolitan Transportation Planning," Cato senior fellow Randal O'Toole reviews more than 75 regional plans to show how they lead to irrational policies. "Long-range transportation planning necessarily relies on uncertain forecasts," O'Toole writes. "Planners also set qualitative goals such as 'vibrant communities' and quantifiable but incomparable goals such as 'protecting historic resources.' Such vagaries result in a politicized process that cannot hope to find the most effective transportation solutions."

O'Toole criticizes existing plans for coming up short of ideal standards. "No plan did sensitivity analyses of critical assumptions. None bothered to project potential benefits or cost-effectiveness of projects considered. All but a handful of plans failed to include any realistic alternatives, and many failed to project the effects of the proposed plan on transportation."

This results in increased congestion. "The Texas Transportation Institute estimates that congestion costs the nation's commuters $78 billion in 2005 and that the amount of time people waste sitting in congestion has hextupled since 1982," O'Toole notes. "That has forced drivers to waste 2.9 billion gallons of fuel a year, adding 28 billion tons of CO2 to the atmosphere."

O'Toole concludes that long-range plans are doomed to failure and suggests instead that metropolitan areas focus on meeting short-term goals, use quantifiable standards, and impose user fees. Congress will have the opportunity to review planning requirements when the federal gasoline tax comes up for reauthorization in 2009. "Long-range regional problems are simply too complex for anyone to predict or fix," O'Toole concludes. "Congress should repeal long-range planning requirements in federal law and replace them with a short-range planning process built around incentives and user fees."


| More

Comments

Add Your Comment

You are solely responsible for the content of your comments. We reserve the right to remove comments that are considered profane, vulgar, obscene, factually inaccurate, off-topic, or considered a personal attack.

In Our Library

White Papers | Exclusives Reports | Webinar Archives | Best Practices and Case Studies
Meeting Constituents Where They Are With Dynamic, Real-Time Mobile Engagement
Leveraging the proven and open Kofax Mobile Capture Platform, organizations can rapidly integrate powerful mobile engagement solutions across the spectrum of mobile image capture, mobile data capture and complete mobile process integration. Kofax differentiates itself by extending capture to mobility, supporting multiple points of constituent engagement. Kofax solutions dynamically orchestrate the user’s mobile experience from a single platform—reducing time to market, improving process perf
Public Safety 2019
Motorola conducted an industry survey on the latest trends in public safety communications. The results provide an outlook of what technology is in store for your agency in the next five years. Download the results to gain this valuable insight.
Improving Emergency Response with Digital Communications
Saginaw County, Mich., increases interoperability, communication and collaboration with a digital voice and data network, as well as modern computer-aided dispatch.
View All

Featured Papers