Government Technology

Proposals Would Shift Utility Infrastructure Costs to Ratepayers


Adding Extra Fees

February 19, 2013 By Jim Malewitz

Electricity and gas bills could creep higher in several states, as lawmakers consider whether to allow utilities to charge customers upfront for upgrading aging infrastructure.

Utilities typically recoup costs only after a project’s completion, as part of negotiations with regulators that take place every few years. But legislation in at least four states — Indiana, Maryland, Missouri and New Jersey — would let some tack on extra fees, called cost trackers, to immediately pay to improve pipelines and the electrical grid.

The possible shift in obligation has irked consumer advocates, who argue that monopoly companies have shirked their basic responsibility to keep systems up-to-date, pocketing the cost savings, only to now ask customers to pay extra.

Such fees typically add no more than a few dollars to residents’ monthly bills, but in states that allow multiple trackers, critics say they add up — particularly for poor families or seniors with fixed incomes.

“It certainly is frustrating to consumers,” says Janee Briesemeister, who tracks utility legislation for the AARP. “For seniors, every dollar makes a difference.”

The debates come as states, either through legislation or rulemaking, are increasingly breaking with tradition and approving  cost trackers for infrastructure, as Stateline has reported.

The mechanism has been used in the past, but only to recover costs from unforeseeable events, such as a quick spike in fuel prices or fallout from a disaster.

Proponents say multi-million dollar upgrades to equipment, necessitated by new federal regulations, changing economics and decades of wear and tear, are urgent but too costly to absorb into normal rates.

“Financially weak utilities don’t do good things for customers,” says Lawrence Borgard, president of Integrys Energy Group. “Unless we have reasonable cost recovery systems, Wall Street is going to chew us up.”

The Maryland Legislature will likely send the governor a bill allowing gas companies to charge extra to shore up a system that relies heavily on cast iron pipes — those that turn brittle over the years and are especially prone to failure. 

Following deadly explosions in Pennsylvania and California in 2010 and 2011, federal regulators have been pushing states to ensure such old pipes are replaced.

Maryland has experienced 31 “significant” pipeline incidents since 2002, though eight were caused by excavation damage, according to the U.S. Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration.  The incidents caused more than $13 million in damage, killed one person and injured 16 others. The proposed trackers there would generate up to $36 million for improvements through fees capped at $2 per customer.

Maryland regulators have repeatedly denied tracker requests in the past. The legislation wouldn’t require them to approve requests, but it would make approval more likely.  

In New Jersey, where Hurricane Sandy’s winds and waters knocked out power for 7 million people for as long as two weeks, the growing threat of extreme weather has prompted lawmakers to push the change. Legislation there would require electric and gas companies to meet new standards for reliability and response, necessitating new infrastructure. That might include “smart meters” to pinpoint outages more quickly and systems that redirect power when a generating station fails. Companies could recoup those costs through trackers.

But critics say utilities don’t need the extra revenue — even if costly upgrades are needed.

“It almost makes the utility industry a risk-free business,” says Kerwin Olson, executive director of Citizens Action Coalition, a group fighting tracker legislation in Indiana, where regulators already allow electric, gas and water companies to add some fees.

Olson and others say the combination of trackers essentially deregulates public utilities. “It’s a vicious assault on the widely accepted regulatory compact between consumers and monopoly utilities,” he says.

That newest proposal would allow electric and gas companies to use trackers to finance upgrades to a wide range of equipment, including pipelines, transmission wires and storage systems. It is similar to a Missouri proposal that would apply to electric utilities. That bill is stuck in committee.  

The Indiana legislation sailed through the Senate, but is likely to face resistance in the House. Governor Mike Pence, a Republican, has not said whether he will sign it.

Reprint courtesy of Stateline, a nonpartisan, nonprofit news service of the Pew Center on the States that provides daily reporting and analysis on trends in state policy.
 


| More

Comments

Add Your Comment

You are solely responsible for the content of your comments. We reserve the right to remove comments that are considered profane, vulgar, obscene, factually inaccurate, off-topic, or considered a personal attack.

In Our Library

White Papers | Exclusives Reports | Webinar Archives | Best Practices and Case Studies
Fresh Ideas In Online Security for Public Safety Organizations
Lesley Carhart, Senior Information Security Specialist at Motorola Solutions, knows that online and computer security are more challenging than ever. Personal smartphones, removable devices like USB storage drives, and social media have a significant impact on security. In “Fresh Ideas in Online Security for Public Safely Organizations,” Lesley provides recommendations to improve your online security against threats from social networks, removable devices, weak passwords and digital photos.
Meeting Constituents Where They Are With Dynamic, Real-Time Mobile Engagement
Leveraging the proven and open Kofax Mobile Capture Platform, organizations can rapidly integrate powerful mobile engagement solutions across the spectrum of mobile image capture, mobile data capture and complete mobile process integration. Kofax differentiates itself by extending capture to mobility, supporting multiple points of constituent engagement. Kofax solutions dynamically orchestrate the user’s mobile experience from a single platform—reducing time to market, improving process perf
Public Safety 2019
Motorola conducted an industry survey on the latest trends in public safety communications. The results provide an outlook of what technology is in store for your agency in the next five years. Download the results to gain this valuable insight.
View All

Featured Papers