March 23, 2010 By Andy Opsahl
Distributing meeting agendas to Sacramento City Council members has become less expensive and greener now that members receive agendas electronically on Amazon Kindle e-book readers and netbooks.
Before the switch, the city consumed one ream of paper per day for each council member for all necessary documents, according to Sacramento City Clerk Shirley Concolino. That amount of paper cost $1,500 per year, per council member. In October 2009, Concolino persuaded the Council to mandate that the city work toward becoming 80 percent paperless over the next several years. Concolino said she knew employee satisfaction with the user experience of electronic documents would determine compliance. In January 2010, she purchased a few Kindles and netbooks and offered demonstrations to Council members and their staffers. Enthusiasm for devices grew quickly, she said.
"Even Council Member Robbie Waters, by his own admission, is probably the least tech-savvy council member and had been unwilling to try new things. He became an ambassador for us," Concolino said.
The netbooks are more popular than the Kindles among the members, Concolino reported. She said they found the netbooks easier to navigate because they function more like everyday computers. Using Adobe Acrobat, they can also highlight sections -- similar to a well known feature of the Kindle. However, members who use the Kindle can select words they don't understand and immediately get definitions, a function that's unavailable on the netbooks.
Concolino said the Kindles are also better for users who want to magnify their font sizes. "Obviously you can increase the font on a netbook, but it doesn't line up as well as it does in a Kindle," Concolino said.
Governments that are interested in transitioning their workers to Kindles or netbooks should expect to spend roughly $300 per employee, she said.
Usage of netbooks and Kindles will likely increase in Sacramento government during the next few months. Concolino said other boards and commissions are inquiring about getting their own machines.
The work required for transitioning end-users and IT staff onto the devices is minimal. "We get rave reviews when it comes to our customer service and training," Concolino said.
This Digital Communities white paper highlights discussions with IT officials in four counties that have adopted shared services models. Our aim was to learn about the obstacles these governments have faced when it comes to shared services and what it takes to overcome those roadblocks. We also spoke with several members of the IT industry who have thought long and hard about these issues. The paper offers some best practices for shared government-to-government services, but also points out challenges that government and industry still must overcome before this model gains widespread adoption.