Government Technology

Sex Offenders' GPS Devices Not a Silver Bullet, States Say



January 31, 2009 By

GPS monitoring -- embraced as a simple technological solution for tracking the whereabouts of convicted sex offenders -- is proving to be something less than a silver bullet for state and local public safety agencies.

Convinced that GPS monitoring was the answer to the sex offender problem, judges and lawmakers began mandating the technology for high-profile parolees. Beginning in 2005, the technology was widely deployed as means to ensure that offenders complied with the terms of their release, such as staying a safe distance from schools or a victim's home.

Monitoring systems typically consist of a GPS receiver/portable tracking device, radio frequency transmitter, stationary charging unit, cellular telephone and computer software to review GPS data. The devices allow officials to track the parolees' whereabouts -- when everything works properly and when offender cooperates.

But there are problems with the way the technology is used and monitored. False alarms number in the thousands in some jurisdictions, straining manpower and casting doubt on the viability of GPS as a tracking tool for high-profile felons.

In Arizona, a 2007 legislative study found more than 35,000 false alerts by 140 subjects wearing the GPS-monitoring devices.

In California, the percentage of transient parolees, those who've been declared homeless, has increased by 900 percent since a law was passed that included GPS as part of the solution. Now, officials say, they're guessing about where the offenders are because more have become transient and the GPS monitoring can be unreliable, especially when the offenders lack real housing where they can charge the devices.

And in Connecticut, officials are pushing for a state-run monitoring facility to keep track of offenders being monitored by GPS after numerous false alarms involving several subjects, including one whose case prompted action.

Though public safety officials typically agree that GPS is a valuable tool, they say it's not a replacement for personal contact with the subject, his co-workers, family and friends that keeps the offender honest.

Released, Arrested, Released

Connecticut's move for a proposed monitoring facility resulted from a recent re-arrest of a sex offender.

After serving 24 years in prison for multiple sexual assaults, David Pollitt was released and put on probation in September 2007. Pollitt was confined to his sister's residence and required to wear a GPS anklet that tracked his whereabouts. In September 2008, Pollitt was re-arrested after allegedly violating conditions of his parole by leaving the property.

However, Pollitt and his lawyer contended that the GPS unit provided a false alert. In fact, they contend that during the one-year period after Pollitt's release, the unit sent more than 40 false alarms.

Pro Tech Monitoring Inc., a subcontractor for G4S Justice Services, eventually wrote a letter to the court that said it couldn't say conclusively that Pollitt had left the property, according to Pollitt's lawyer, John Kaloidis. Two days after Pollitt's arrest, the warrant was withdrawn.

"A tech went to the home where my client is and said there was a problem with the device," Kaloidis said. "[The signal] bounces off cell phone towers, and there are certain points it can bounce off. It didn't find the street where my client was and bounced him to the next street over."

Pro Tech didn't return phone calls and e-mails to discuss the case.

There were also other problems with the tracking device and its monitoring that added up to the false alerts.

Once, Pollitt was plotted on GPS to have been more than 400 feet from his residence at 12:59 p.m. Just seconds later, he was plotted at the residence, according to a report by the Court Support Services Division of the Connecticut Judicial Branch.


| More

Comments

leonard Sipes    |    Commented January 29, 2009

See "DC Public Safety" at http://media.csosa.gov for a new television show on GPS supervision of criminal offenders. Radio shows on the same subject are available. DC Public Safety is the social media service of the federal Court Services and Offender Supervision Agency

leonard Sipes    |    Commented January 29, 2009

See "DC Public Safety" at http://media.csosa.gov for a new television show on GPS supervision of criminal offenders. Radio shows on the same subject are available. DC Public Safety is the social media service of the federal Court Services and Offender Supervision Agency

leonard Sipes    |    Commented January 29, 2009

See "DC Public Safety" at http://media.csosa.gov for a new television show on GPS supervision of criminal offenders. Radio shows on the same subject are available. DC Public Safety is the social media service of the federal Court Services and Offender Supervision Agency

ITChief    |    Commented February 13, 2009

Another example of non-technical worshippers of the Silicon God making decisions in hopes that technology will be a panacea.

ITChief    |    Commented February 13, 2009

Another example of non-technical worshippers of the Silicon God making decisions in hopes that technology will be a panacea.

ITChief    |    Commented February 13, 2009

Another example of non-technical worshippers of the Silicon God making decisions in hopes that technology will be a panacea.

Daniel Hock    |    Commented March 19, 2009

My wife and I have the full patent to transmit immediate alerts through cell phones to authorities and the public. This device gives proximity alerts IMMEDIATELY. If PTM would contact me ,this device can be implemented IMMEDIATLY. PTM please call, you have had my patent for 3 years now. Stop the killings.

Daniel Hock    |    Commented March 19, 2009

My wife and I have the full patent to transmit immediate alerts through cell phones to authorities and the public. This device gives proximity alerts IMMEDIATELY. If PTM would contact me ,this device can be implemented IMMEDIATLY. PTM please call, you have had my patent for 3 years now. Stop the killings.

Daniel Hock    |    Commented March 19, 2009

My wife and I have the full patent to transmit immediate alerts through cell phones to authorities and the public. This device gives proximity alerts IMMEDIATELY. If PTM would contact me ,this device can be implemented IMMEDIATLY. PTM please call, you have had my patent for 3 years now. Stop the killings.

Getting down w/ the real for real    |    Commented August 1, 2010

Women and children aren't the only one's who wants to be safe, So what you're saying is is as long as person is not a sex offender, you wouldn't care who lives in your neighborhood ha? . When dealing with Criminals, thugs, armed robbers, stick up boys, home invasions, serial killings,and kidnappings. You think that's fair to the rest of the people who wants to be safe. And at the same time, you want to boost up their self esteem, by granting them more Constitutional Rights, once released to society, than a sex offender. That's cause the Govt. is scared of the regular criminals and thugs. You know they will retaliate and become America's worst nightmare if you discriminate against them. You little cowards. Being that they are straight up killers. But a sex offender 9 times out of 10 he ain't really dangerous, they just manipulate young boys or girls to date them. And you know if you discriminate against them as far as Constitutional Rights. Chances are they are not gonna really do anything about it.

Getting down w/ the real for real    |    Commented August 1, 2010

Women and children aren't the only one's who wants to be safe, So what you're saying is is as long as person is not a sex offender, you wouldn't care who lives in your neighborhood ha? . When dealing with Criminals, thugs, armed robbers, stick up boys, home invasions, serial killings,and kidnappings. You think that's fair to the rest of the people who wants to be safe. And at the same time, you want to boost up their self esteem, by granting them more Constitutional Rights, once released to society, than a sex offender. That's cause the Govt. is scared of the regular criminals and thugs. You know they will retaliate and become America's worst nightmare if you discriminate against them. You little cowards. Being that they are straight up killers. But a sex offender 9 times out of 10 he ain't really dangerous, they just manipulate young boys or girls to date them. And you know if you discriminate against them as far as Constitutional Rights. Chances are they are not gonna really do anything about it.

Getting down w/ the real for real    |    Commented August 1, 2010

Women and children aren't the only one's who wants to be safe, So what you're saying is is as long as person is not a sex offender, you wouldn't care who lives in your neighborhood ha? . When dealing with Criminals, thugs, armed robbers, stick up boys, home invasions, serial killings,and kidnappings. You think that's fair to the rest of the people who wants to be safe. And at the same time, you want to boost up their self esteem, by granting them more Constitutional Rights, once released to society, than a sex offender. That's cause the Govt. is scared of the regular criminals and thugs. You know they will retaliate and become America's worst nightmare if you discriminate against them. You little cowards. Being that they are straight up killers. But a sex offender 9 times out of 10 he ain't really dangerous, they just manipulate young boys or girls to date them. And you know if you discriminate against them as far as Constitutional Rights. Chances are they are not gonna really do anything about it.

shadow    |    Commented August 4, 2010

some people have these damn monitors on there legs and aint true sex offenders i know cuz i got one on cuz when i was 19 a girl lied at a party about her age. so not everyone deserves this torture. these monitors are huge annoying and a eye sore. the goverment needs to learn how to decide whos a real offender or just some one in the wrong place at the wrong time.some ppl on these, ARE real thugs who got screwed by a b----.

shadow    |    Commented August 4, 2010

some people have these damn monitors on there legs and aint true sex offenders i know cuz i got one on cuz when i was 19 a girl lied at a party about her age. so not everyone deserves this torture. these monitors are huge annoying and a eye sore. the goverment needs to learn how to decide whos a real offender or just some one in the wrong place at the wrong time.some ppl on these, ARE real thugs who got screwed by a b----.

shadow    |    Commented August 4, 2010

some people have these damn monitors on there legs and aint true sex offenders i know cuz i got one on cuz when i was 19 a girl lied at a party about her age. so not everyone deserves this torture. these monitors are huge annoying and a eye sore. the goverment needs to learn how to decide whos a real offender or just some one in the wrong place at the wrong time.some ppl on these, ARE real thugs who got screwed by a b----.


Add Your Comment

You are solely responsible for the content of your comments. We reserve the right to remove comments that are considered profane, vulgar, obscene, factually inaccurate, off-topic, or considered a personal attack.

In Our Library

White Papers | Exclusives Reports | Webinar Archives | Best Practices and Case Studies
Improving Emergency Response with Digital Communications
Saginaw County, Mich., increases interoperability, communication and collaboration with a digital voice and data network, as well as modern computer-aided dispatch.
Reduce Talk Time in Your Support Center by 40%
As the amount of information available to citizens and employees grows each year, so do customer expectations for efficient service. Contextual Knowledge makes information easy to find, dropping resolution times and skyrocketing satisfaction.
Emerging Technology Adoption in Local Government
In a recent survey conducted by Government Technology, 125 local government leaders shared their challenges, benefits and priorities when adopting emerging technologies such as cloud, mobility and IP. Read how your jurisdiction’s adoption of technology compares to your peers.
View All

Featured Papers